Report Here : Missing and incorrectly evaluated items

[Emmerald]

In order for me not to lose any reports of missing or incorrectly evaluated items, please post your "bug" reports in this thread. Thanks!

Known bugs:
- Crafted items with randomly generated properties are entirely missing from the list
- Zandalarian Hero Badge is not appropriately valued due to current limitations in the list generator

[Kuff]

Hey Emmerald! i've found this http://wow.curse.com/forums/details/24258/ about Ramdom Enchantments...

check out http://www.wowwiki.com/SuffixId...

I will come back with something..

Emmerald: Thanks for looking, but that doesn't help me here. The problem is, I need the "seed ID" that is used by the game to determine which random property ID's are possible for any given item, not a list of possible random property ID's. The items table I have has the base items and the "seed ID", but I don't have the table connecting that ID to actual random property ID's.

In other words, if we look at for example Abyssal Leather Leggings (http://www.wowhead.com/?item=20665), we can see that it has three possible random enchantments. Currently I have no way of finding out which from the database I have. One option I have is to construct such a table by going through every item in Wowhead with random properties, record down the possible stats and names, and store that in a new table with item ID + variants. From that table, I can then generate all the possible items for my lists.

I haven't yet written a script that does that, in the hopes of getting such a table directly from Wowhead.

[Felyae]

Slightly OT but one question just came to my mind while reading the info page:
defense = defense rating or pure defense (=2.4 defense rating)? ^^

[DJNW]

Hi, I've noticed that whilst scourgebane is on the cat dps trinket list, the upgraded physical argent dawn trinkets are missing.
Even the blue one's just a wee bit more oomphy than scourgebane.  +81ap and and AD comission whil I'm farming Strat/Scholo? Yes please!
http://www.wowwiki.com/Seal_of_the_Dawn
http://www.wowwiki.com/Mark_of_the_Champion_%28Physical%29

Emmerald: Hmm... they definitely used to be there... I wonder what's happened. Thanks for pointing out.

[tehchopper]

I believe Radiant Spencerite is a fake... i could be wrong ... but it seams like it

Emmerald: Thanks, I'll put it on the "invalid items" list in the script.

[Maxhunter]

Ashtongue Talisman of Equilibrium seems to be missing from the Feral Cat High-Gear DPS Gear List.

Emmerald: I'll have to consider how to value that appropriately. The basics is simple, but in the calculated rotation, the proc will be buffing all Shreds, thus giving it more value than it would statistically get. Also, if you Mangle before Rip, there's a chance you will get that bonus also to the bleed part. The only ability not buffed would be Mangle.

[Rakanik]

That's kind of a tough one to evaluate to kitty points.   It came up before, and the calculations of a few of the board folks put it at about 50 kitty points - which puts it firmly below any of the trinkets you'd expect to have equiped by the time you could get it.

[Emmerald]

I moderated this thread to remove all posts that no longer are valid. I will also moderate out all discussions in this thread. They should be had in the non-sticky threads.

[AmadisAnguiano]

I just got Vashj down with my guild, and while it didn't drop, I was wondering if you had a rating for [Prism of Inner Calm]? I remember seeing it on an older version of your lists, but I can't seem to find it now. Thank you for your time.

Emmerald: That's an interesting one and certainly useful for DPS in some special situations. However, I have no idea how I would rank that as it does not directly add to your DPS.

[Chardys]

They aren't likely to top the lists, but I did notice that the Stormpike/Frostwolf insignias (which give health regen and dodge) seem to be missing from the bear mitigation lists.

[WVUSax]

How about adding Idols and Enchants to your gear lists?

Emmerald: Idols, no. They are so few and the choice is usually very simple. Enchants, though, yes, I've had that in my mind for a long time. I've just never had the time how to figure out how to properly extract them from the database. I've done some work on it, but it's incomplete so far.

[AmadisAnguiano]

I think Blackened Naaru Sliver is missing. According to the comments on WoWHead:

At 1 attack per sec, you average 10 sec to proc, 220 ap for 10 sec to build it up, 440 ap for 10 sec once it's up, and a 45 sec cooldown after it procs. (220 x 10 + 440 x 10) / 55 = 120 AP average.

So I'd figure it's score is 197.9 points on Cat High-Gear and 171.8 regular Cat, but someone might want to check that math out.

Emmerald: Thanks for the info.

[Rizzen]

Hey Emmerald the new items from the Midsummer Boss are missing more then likely due to the fact he just hit the live servers. There seems to be 2 for each spec.
(bear)
Icebound Cloak
Hailstone Pendant
(cat)
The Frost Lord's War Cloak
Amulet of Bitter Hatred.

[AmadisAnguiano]

In regards to the Midsummer gear, for the cat gear at least, the cloak is identical to the [Blood Knight War Cloak] and the neck is identical to the [Choker of Vile Intent]. I bet the other pieces have matching stats to other already existent gear, too.

[Hatred]

The tank necklace seems rather interesting as it has 19 hit rating instead of 19 agility on the corresponding badge necklace.